Seen during the Joburg Art Fair: Simon Njami hangs out with Boer War Hero

Wednesday, March 31, 2010




The other night we went to watch Zander Blom's band in a bar in Joburg called the The Kitchener. If you're from Cape Town, think The Kimberly Hotel, but nicer. The thing is, though, that the Kitchener, in it's apparent 'harmless' colonial nostalgia, is named from Earl Kitchener, the famous British hero of both the South African War and World War II.

During the South African War (or Second Boer War) Kitchener arrived with Lord Roberts and the massive British reinforcements of December 1899, officially holding the title of chief of staff. Amongst other things, Kitchener was the inventor (or at least first implementer) of the the concentration camp, and the scorched earth policy. In a brutal campaign, these strategies removed civilian support from the Boers with a scorched earth policy of destroying Boer farms, slaughtering livestock, building blockhouses, and moving women, children and the elderly into concentration camps. Conditions in these camps, which had been conceived by Roberts as a form of controlling the families whose farms he had destroyed, began to degenerate rapidly as the large influx of Boers outstripped the ability of the minuscule British force to cope. The camps lacked space, food, sanitation, medicine, and medical care, leading to rampant disease and a staggering 34.4% death rate for those Boers who entered.

Other than a brief South African history lesson, the point is that he was not a particularly nice guy. In fact, one might even suggest it's a bit problematic to name a bar after him, more so for young (mostly white) South Africans to drink there there relishing in the quaint nostalgic fascism of the place, which features images of Kitchener prevalently on the walls.
Possibly MOST disturbing was the fact that supposed hardcore postcolonial theorist, Simon Njami was lounging on their couches all night. This worries me.

Perhaps some critique of both our nostalgia and our leisure-time is appropriate.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Coming from one who regularly visits the Kimberley hotel.....rich.

April 9, 2010 at 2:32 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oh please: a post-colonial theorist can't visit a bar because it's named after an admittedly horrendous warcrimes enthusiast?

Does that mean that because I don't subscribe to the ANC's version of struggle history I can't drive on Beyers Naude? Or fly out from OR Tambo Airport? Or buy a bagel and a frappacino in Nelson Mandela Square?

Names become arbitrary through use and overuse: we don't tacitly support the ideologies of historical figures simply because we interact with infrastructure named after them. If we did, it would be an abominably PC world to exist in...

April 9, 2010 at 3:54 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

but it's not just a name... there're pictures of him everywhere. and no, kimberly's not much better...

April 11, 2010 at 8:29 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oooo, pictures, that makes it so much more threatening...

If I was Njami, I'd be pissed about some undergrad-level attack on my integrity, accompanied by unauthorised photos of me posted by little white kids who clearly need a cause they can argue while Rome burns. In this sense, I agree: pictures are offensive. Offensively stupid and misguided...

April 12, 2010 at 12:08 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

yeah

fuck the little white kids

they don't even go here

April 14, 2010 at 11:08 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Collaborators

  • Linda Stupart
  • Robert Sloon
  • Natasha Norman
  • Andrew Putter
  • Ian Grose
  • Matthew King
  • Tony East
  • Craig Groenewald
  • Mike Rance
  • Natalie Pereira
  • Robert Sloon
  • Jem Smith
  • Jon Keevy
  • Georgina Gratrix
  • Colin Groenewald
  • Simon Tamblyn
  • Josh De Kock
  • Jonathan Kope
  • Shruthi Nair
  • Rebecca Haysom
  • Lauren Palte
  • Lauren Franklin
  • Matthew Hindley
  • Rose Kotze
  • Katherine Jacobs
  • Gareth Morris-Davies
  • Daniella Mooney
  • Karen Graaff
  • Andrew Lamprecht
  • Michael Michael
  • Michael Ilias Linders
  • Ed Young
  • James Webb
  • Daniella Mooney
  • Margaret Stone
  • Marco Filby
  • Hugh Upsher
  • Rowan Smith
  • Myer Taub
  • Ron T Beck
  • Marc Barben
  • Justin Brett
  • Paul Grose
  • Andrzej Nowicki
  • Johke Steenkamp
  • Julie Donald
  • Anna Stielau
  • Tim Liebbrandt
  • Jason Basson
  • Rebecca Haysom
  • Genevieve Louw
  • Charles Maggs
  • Wayne Barker

Return to ArtHeat

About Mixtape

Mixtape is a blog run (loosely) by Linda Stupart as a manifestation of a project in which she collaborates with a large group of smart, interesting, wonderful cultural producers. As such, Mixtape documents these collaborations. More than that, though, the blog serves as a space for each member of the project to post whatever they like: Tell us what they’re making, thinking, doing or, even, feeling. The blog also forms a space for Linda, a Cape Town based critic, artist, feminist, WWE fan and cultural commentator, to post her writing.

Previously on Mixtape

Mixtape Archives


Subscribe to posts here

Search Mixtape